529: A Developing Story
Below you will find answers to the most frequently asked question that have come in to Agudah’s office in the past week:
- What is a “529” plan?
- Are there any benefits to 529 plans on a state level?
- Are there other potential benefits?
- Why are you telling me this? What changed?
- What does that mean for me, a yeshiva parent?
- You said that a change occurred at the federal level to expand 529s to K-12 expenses. What does that mean for the state deduction opportunities mentioned?
- Can I realize a state tax deduction even if I need to use the money sooner than expected?
- What is the Agudah doing about this now?
- What can I do?
+ Top 5 Questions to ask your tax advisor
What is a “529” plan?
- A 529 plan is a special, tax-advantaged account designed to encourage saving for college (including certain post-secondary yeshivos). The federal tax advantage is that earnings on funds contributed to 529 accounts are not federally taxed.
Example: Parent deposits $1,000 into Child’s 529 account at Child’s birth. The 529 account is worth $2,500 when Child attends college. If the $2,500 is properly used to pay college expenses, there is no federal tax on the $1,500 earned.
Are there any benefits to 529 plans at the state level?
Yes! In many states, the principal contributed to the plan is deductible for state income taxes. State laws on this point vary widely.
Example: NYS Parent deposits $10,000 into Child’s NYS 529 account to save for college. If Parent’s income was $100,000 that year, after the 529 contribution, NYS will view that income as $90,000. Depending on Parent’s specific tax circumstances, Parent can realize a NYS tax benefit of several hundred dollars. NYC residents, and those in higher tax brackets, would realize significantly greater tax benefits.
Any there other potential 529 benefits?
Yes. Upromise, a Sallie Mae company, offers automatic deposits to 529 accounts, at no cost to account holders, of up to 5% of retail, travel, and other purchases when paid by a Upromise linked credit card. These free contributions may not be game-changing, but they add up.
Also, the availability of a tax-advantaged account, with tax advantages for contributors in certain states, incentivizes assistance from friends or family who may not have otherwise assisted.
Why are you telling me this? What’s changed?
While 529 accounts have been available for use toward paying college expenses for decades, effective 1/1/2018, federal law expands the allowable use of 529s to include K-12 expenses.
What does that mean for me, a yeshiva parent?
In addition to being a significant, symbolic, national school-choice victory, encouraged by Agudath Israel and other groups as part of our tax advocacy efforts on the federal level, it means that a new, beneficial vehicle will be available for the tremendous expense our community bears in paying yeshiva tuitions. Parents (and others) can set up and deposit money in 529 accounts have that money grow, federally tax-free, and use the funds for K-12 yeshiva tuition.
You said that a change occurred at the federal level to expand 529s to K-12 expenses. What does that mean for the state deduction opportunities mentioned?
That is a critical question now. If allowed, this would be of further assistance to yeshiva parents. K-12 state deductibility would allow parents to attain long-term (federal) benefits, and more immediate (state) benefits.
Caveat #1: States have not yet legislatively reacted to the new federal law. Some states may adjust their laws to favorably embrace K-12 expenses to complement their existing college savings deduction benefits, others may not.
Caveat #2: Benefit specifics vary widely from state to state. New York allows a maximum deduction of $10,000 per year
for married fi ling joint filers. New Jersey offers NO state tax deduction, although it does offer a limited matching college
scholarship program for 529 deposits. (More on that coming soon from Agudah’s NJ Director, Rabbi Avi Schnall.) Colorado
allows generous deductions for 529 contributions. States like Florida or Texas, that have no state income tax, obviously
do not offer state tax deductions.
Excellent overview of state tax benefits, limitations, and application links here.
Can I realize a state tax deduction even if I need to use the money sooner than expected?
The greatest tax benefit will come from keeping funds in the 529 account for a longer period, so growth occurs federally
tax-free. However, it is possible to realize the state tax benefit, if applicable, even if funds are withdrawn for K-12 tuition
sooner, if the state-specific holding period is complied with. Check with your tax advisor for details.
What is the Agudah doing about this now?
Agudah is engaged in a coordinated, multi-state approach on this issue, following the successful K-12 expansion at the
federal level. The multi-pronged approach includes:
1) Advocating that states which do not currently oﬀer a state 529 benefit, now introduce one.
2) Advocating that states embrace the new, broader federal definition of 529s which encompasses K-12 expenses.
3) Defensively moving to protect 529s at the state level from current eff orts to limit its applicability, in response to a
change in the federal law that states may not concur with.
4) Advocating to raise annual deduction limits and streamline other plan limitations.
What can I do?
* Stay tuned for updates from us and other sources on this developing issue.
* Consult with your personal accountant or financial advisor to determine if a 529 account is appropriate for you.
* We have opened a dedicated inbox – email@example.com – for comments on this issue. Due to the volume of submissions expected nationally, we intend to read every comment, but you will likely not receive a response beyond an automated acknowledgment. This mailbox is NOT designed to be a forum for individual tax questions.
Top 5 questions to ask your tax advisor now:
- Is a 529 account right for me?
- What are the specific benefits and limitations of 529 accounts in my state?
- Am I better off waiting until my state clarifies ts 529 rules before taking action?
- What impact does 529 savings have on financial aid?
- What is the interplay between 529 contributions and gift tax limits?
None of the above should be considered tax advice of any kind. As mentioned, please consult with your financial or tax advisor to determine your best course of action.